ISSN 2617-4162 e-ISSN 2617-4170
en English
Submit an article
Social and Legal Studios

Article

Download article

Problems of regulating liability for criminal offences against the life and health of a person committed in the sphere of healthcare

Oleh Marmura

Received 07.11.2022, Revised 03.12.2022, Accepted 26.12.2022

Abstract

The Criminal Code of Ukraine provides for several special provisions on liability for violations against human life and health committed in the healthcare sphere, the application of which gives rise to many difficulties and law enforcement errors. However, the lack of consistency of such provisions establishes risks of non-compliance with the principle of fairness in bringing a person to criminal liability and imposing punishment. The purpose of the research is to identify the most optimal solution to the problem of legislative regulation of liability for causing harm or establishing a threat of harm in the healthcare sphere. The key research method is a logical and legal study of the Ukrainian criminal law provisions related to liability for healthcare offences. Based on the results of the study, it is proposed to construct Articles 134, 139, 140, 142 and 143 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine according to the same scheme: in the third part of Article 134 and the first parts of the rest of these provisions, criminal liability for the acts provided for therein should be linked to the establishment of a danger to the patient’s life or the threat of causing serious bodily harm; in the following parts of these provisions, to provide for the rules on qualified criminal offences under the scheme “the same act if it caused moderate or serious bodily harm”, and the rules on particularly qualified criminal offences under the scheme “the same act if it caused the death of the patient”. Based on the current sanctions of these provisions, and the sanctions of the general provisions on criminal liability for negligent infliction of bodily harm, the author proposes typical penalty limits for the proposed provisions. The author substantiates the expediency of excluding Articles 132, 141 and 145 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine. The conclusions drawn within the framework of this research can be used in lawmaking activities to develop amendments to the Criminal Code of Ukraine, and in law enforcement activities to qualify criminal offences committed in the healthcare sphere.

Keywords:

failure to perform duties, violations by medical professionals, violation of patient rights, transplantation procedure, disclosure of medical secrets, bodily harm, causing death

https://doi.org/10.32518/2617-4162-2022-5-4-33-38

Retrieved from Vol. 5, No. 4, 2022

Pages 33-38

References Suggested citation

References

[1] Antoniuk, N. (2020). Differentiation of criminal liability of medical professionals. Wiadomości Lekarskie, LXXIII (12; Part 2), 2728-2732. doi: 10.36740/WLek202012205.

[2] Brych, L.P. (2013). Theory of differentiation of crimes. Lviv: Lviv State University of Internal Affairs.

[3] Chernikov, Ie.E. (2020). Criminal liability for the improper performance of professional duties by a medical or pharmaceutical professional (Doctoral thesis, Odesa State University of Internal Affairs, Odesa, Ukraine).

[4] Criminal Сode of Ukraine. (2001, April). Retrieved from https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/2341-14#n882.

[5] Fil, I.M. (2018). Criminal law and criminological counteraction to improper performance of professional duties by the medical or pharmaceutical workers (Doctoral thesis, Koretsky Institute of State and Law of National Academy of Science of Ukraine, Kyiv, Ukraine).

[6] Gafurova, N., Khidoyatov, B., & Sunnatov, V. (2020). Criminal responsibility of medical workers: National and foreign experience. International Journal of Pharmaceutical Research, 12(2), 153-165. doi: 10.31838/ijpr/2020.12.02.0024.

[7] Gutorova, N., Zhytnyi, O., & Kahanovska, T. (2019) Medical negligence subject to criminal law. Wiadomości Lekarskie, 72(11 cz. 1), 2161-2166. doi: 10.36740/WLek201911118.

[8] Law of Ukraine No. 2801-XII “Fundamentals of Ukrainian Legislation on Health Care”. (1992, November). Retrieved from https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/2801-12#Text.

[9] Lykhova, S., Ustynova, I., Husar, O., & Tolkachova, I. (2019). Topical issues of criminal liability of medical or pharmaceutical workers under the Criminal Code of Ukraine (Article 140 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine). International Journal of Recent Technology and Engineering, 8(4S), 87-92. doi: 10.35940/ijrte.D1028.1184S19.

[10] Lyzogub, Ya.G. (2005). Problems of criminal liability for the improper performance of professional duties by the medical or pharmaceutical worker. Law of Ukraine, 4, 85-88.

[11] Marmura, O.Z. (2019). Features that qualify crime. Lviv: Lviv State University of Internal Affairs.

[12] Melnyk, M.I., & Khavroniuk, M.I. (Eds.). (2018). Scientific and practical commentary on the Criminal Code of Ukraine (10th ed.). Kyiv: Dakor Publishing House.

[13] Panov, M.I., & Haltsova, V.V. (2013). Problems of improving the criminal law protection of the family, the rights and interests of minors. Bulletin of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine, 9, 106-112.

[14] Paramonova, O.S. (2011). Genitive and proximate object of crime by article 140 of Criminal code of Ukraine. Chonicles of KUL, 2, 259-262.

[15] Shevchuk, O., Kucheryavenko, M., Davydenko, S., & Babaieva, O. (2020). Implementation of the patient’s right to obtain information in the concept “health and human rights”. Revista Amazonia Investiga, 9(29), 288-296. doi: 10.34069/AI/2020.29.05.33.

[16] Shopina, Yu.O. (2020). Criminal liability of medical or pharmaceutical worker for committing a crime associated with the performance of professional duties (Doctoral thesis, National Academy of Internal Affairs, Kyiv, Ukraine).

[17] Slipchenko, T. (2021). Medical secret – legal basis of protection. Actual Problems of Law, 2, 91-96. doi: 10.35774/app2021.02.091. 

[18] Tereshko, Kh. (2020). Lawful disclosure of medical privacy: Some aspects. Law of Ukraine, 3, 97-108. doi: 10.33498/ louu-2020-03-097.

[19] Vallejo-Jiménez, G.A., & Nanclares-Márquez, J. (2019). Legal review of the civil, criminal, and administrative consequences of informed consent violation in medical practice. Colombian Journal of Anesthesiology, 47(2), 107-112. doi: 10.1097/CJ9.0000000000000102.

[20] Verdict of Konotop City and District Court of Sumy Region No. 92123200 in the Case No. 577/3411/20. (2020, October). Retrieved from https://reyestr.court.gov.ua/Review/92123200.

[21] Yevteyeva, D. (2018). Criminal law protection of childhood in Ukraine: Tendencies of legislative reform and directions of further changes. Bulletin of Luhansk State University of Internal Affairs named after E. Didorenko, 1(81), 95-103.

[22] Zabuga, Yu.Yu., & Mykhailichenko, T.O. (2020). Disclosure of medical confidentiality in the context of the spread of COVID-19: The questions of competition of norms. In Legal bases of epidemic safety: Challenges and prospects: Materials of the scientific internet conference with international participation (pp. 106-113). Kharkiv: Pravo.

Suggested citation

Marmura, O. (2022). Problems of regulating liability for criminal offences against the life and health of a person committed in the sphere of healthcare. Social and Legal Studios, 5(4), 33-38. https://doi.org/10.32518/2617-4162-2022-5-4-33-38